Wednesday, February 12, 2025
36 F
Roseville

Immigration and Amnesty: A Constitutional Crisis?

Congressman McClintock delivered the following remarks on the House floor discussing the Constitution and separation of powers: The Constitutional Crisis: What To Do?

If the President can seize legislative power in this manner and then boast to an audience that he, himself has changed the law – then the separation of powers becomes meaningless, and our constitutional Republic will have crossed a very bright line that separates a nation of laws from the unhappy societies where rulers boast the “law is in their mouths.”

If this precedent stands, every succeeding president, Republican and Democrat, will cite it as authority to make or alter law by decree.  This cannot be allowed to happen.

The question occurs, what is the House to do?

It took its first step last week by passing HR 5759 that declares the President’s action unconstitutional and null and void.  This was a symbolic act since the bill is subject to a Presidential veto – but was a warning the President should have heeded.  Obviously, he has not.

What else can the Congress do?  One of the fundamental checks held by the Congress is the power of appropriation – it can close the purse by forbidding the use of federal funds to proceed with this unconstitutional act.  

I realize this is a difficult power to exercise with a dysfunctional Senate.  But a temporary funding measure into January or February would protect us against any prospect of a government shutdown while we try to engage the Senate to rise in defense of the Constitution.  And if the Democratic Senate will not defend our Constitution – and that’s a very strong possibility – a few weeks from now the Republican Senate certainly will.  

Why in the world would we want to lock in federal spending through next September that reflects the priorities of the Democratic Senate that voters just thoroughly repudiated last month?  Why in the world would we want to so greatly weaken our position to insist on the complete defunding of the President’s unconstitutional act in the next session of Congress just three weeks hence?  

Meanwhile, it is imperative that the House take every action available to engage the Supreme Court to resolve this constitutional crisis.  Several states have already filed suit and the House needs to join them.  In addition, the House needs to vote as an institution to challenge this act directly.  This is too important to be treated as an afterthought on current litigation over Obamacare.  It needs to be voted on separately, unequivocally and NOW.  

Since the earliest days of our Republic, the Supreme Court has invalidated legislative acts that conflicted with the Constitution.  Now, it must be called upon to invalidate an executive act that strikes at the core of our Constitution.  Regardless of the ideologies of the individual justices, I cannot believe that any of them can sit idly by as the executive seizes such fundamental powers from the legislative branch.    

On behalf of the House, the Speaker announced last month that we would fight this act tooth and nail.  To adjourn tomorrow having taken only a symbolic vote while abandoning our actual powers to challenge this act undermines the credibility of the House majority. 

Elements on the extreme Left argue that this act was justified due to Congressional inaction over immigration reform.  They fault the House for not adopting a Senate immigration measure, but they forget that the House passed a strong immigration bill this summer that the Senate refused to consider.  

 Since when has Congressional disagreement over legislation been license for the President to legislate himself?  This argument abandons the Constitution and the rule of law for the expediency of one-man-rule. We should recognize such arguments for what they are: the authoritarianism of the extreme Left.  We should reject these arguments and those who make them.

Mr. Speaker, the Roman Republic died when Julius Caesar seized the legislative authority of the Roman Senate.  Repeated acts of usurpation went unchallenged until the constitutional structure of the Republic simply disintegrated.  

Let that not be the epitaph of the American Republic.  Of this crisis, let history record that men and women of good will on both sides of the aisle joined together to defend the Constitution they swore to uphold, and that this generation passed that Constitution – and all the freedoms it has preserved – intact and inviolate – to the many generations who followed. 



Brighter Side

Trending

Job Opening: Sr. Manager, Data Management

5 yrs exp. design, modify, dvlp., write & implement software programming apps & code software. BS deg req’d.

LA-Z-Boy Home Furnishings & Décor in Roseville

Transform your living room and bedroom with La-Z-Boy's comfortable home furniture. Shop for sofas, couches, recliners, chairs, tables, mattress in a box, and more today.

Roseville Pleasant Grove Creek Trail closure for critical repairs

Roseville, Calif. - The trail crossing over Pleasant Grove Creek is closed for critical repairs between Old Coach Drive/Phillips Park and the Orchard View Road trailhead parking lot.

RG Philips Park in Roseville

RG Philips Park "This 6.5 acre park features a children’s...

Roseville welcomes US Quadball West Coast National Qualifier to Maidu Park

Roseville, Calif. - Quadball, an action-packed sport that evolved from the Harry Potter novels, will hold its only West Coast national qualifier Saturday, Feb. 8, and Sunday, Feb. 9 at Maidu Regional Park in Roseville.

Topics

Job Opening: Sr. Manager, Data Management

5 yrs exp. design, modify, dvlp., write & implement software programming apps & code software. BS deg req’d.

LA-Z-Boy Home Furnishings & Décor in Roseville

Transform your living room and bedroom with La-Z-Boy's comfortable home furniture. Shop for sofas, couches, recliners, chairs, tables, mattress in a box, and more today.

Roseville Pleasant Grove Creek Trail closure for critical repairs

Roseville, Calif. - The trail crossing over Pleasant Grove Creek is closed for critical repairs between Old Coach Drive/Phillips Park and the Orchard View Road trailhead parking lot.

RG Philips Park in Roseville

RG Philips Park "This 6.5 acre park features a children’s...

Roseville welcomes US Quadball West Coast National Qualifier to Maidu Park

Roseville, Calif. - Quadball, an action-packed sport that evolved from the Harry Potter novels, will hold its only West Coast national qualifier Saturday, Feb. 8, and Sunday, Feb. 9 at Maidu Regional Park in Roseville.

The Crepe Stop in Roseville

The Crepe Stop in Roseville. Savory & Sweet. Crepes, Pancakes, Waffles, Gelato, Boba Tea.

Roseville Today Super Bowl party picks for Eagles and Chiefs game

Roseville, Calif.- This Sunday at the Superdome in New Orleans, the Philadelphia take on the Chiefs in Super Bowl 59. A super-sized rematch and unofficial national holiday of $8 million dollar commercials, food and drink and a little football.

Quarry Oaks Apartments in Rocklin

Quarry Oaks Apartments in Rocklin, Calif.

Related Articles

Local Spotlight

California Recovery Center in Roseville offers treatment for substance abuse and mental health

California Recovery Center (CRC) is a treatment provider for adults with substance abuse and mental health condition, located in Roseville and serving the greater Sacramento region.

Mobley Pest Services in Roseville serving the community and region for over 20 years

Roseville, Calif.- Fully licensed and bonded, Mobley Pest Services in Roseville has been providing reliable pest control services for well over 20 years. Serving residents and businesses in the greater Placer and Sacramento region, Mobley Pest Services is locally owned and operated in Roseville.

Stanford Ranch Family Dentistry in Rocklin serving the local community since 2000

Rocklin, Calif.- For nearly 24 years, Jason and Heather have grown their successful Stanford Ranch Family Dentistry practice by faithfully serving patients throughout the Rocklin, Roseville, and greater South Placer County region. Their business has grown to now employ over a dozen employees which helps them meet the growing demands of a successful local business.